NHS Tayside: Hospitals, Ratings, Eljamel Inquiry and Pay

What NHS Tayside actually is

NHS Tayside is one of Scotland's fourteen territorial Health Boards — a board plans and directly delivers hospital, community and mental health services for its area as a single organisation, rather than sitting alongside separately managed trusts locally, as happens in England. See our NHS structure explainer for the fuller England-versus-Scotland comparison. NHS Tayside covers the Angus, Dundee City and Perth and Kinross council areas, and traces back to the Tayside Health Board formed in April 1974, itself a successor to the Eastern Regional Hospital Board established in 1948. Since April 2016, services have been delivered locally through three Health and Social Care Partnerships — Angus, Dundee City, and Perth and Kinross.

Concentrating most of the acute and specialist workload on one teaching hospital cuts both ways: real depth of service, but also higher stakes when something goes wrong there — exactly what the inspection and governance findings further down this page show.

The hospitals and sites it runs

NHS Tayside's clinical footprint centres on Dundee, with major sites also in Perth and Angus:

• Ninewells Hospital, Dundee — the board's flagship acute teaching hospital, opened in stages from January 1974 and officially opened by the Queen Mother that October. It houses the Tayside Children's Hospital, a leading cancer and leukaemia research programme, a Frank Gehry-designed Maggie's Centre for cancer support, and is where NHS Tayside pioneered laparoscopic surgery in the UK. It's also where consultant neurosurgeon Sam Eljamel practised until 2013 — the subject of the public inquiry covered later on this page.
• Perth Royal Infirmary — the main general hospital for Perth and Kinross, serving around 182,000 people with roughly 267 beds. It's currently under closer scrutiny than Ninewells: see the Healthcare Improvement Scotland findings below.
• Murray Royal Hospital, Perth — NHS Tayside's largest mental health inpatient site, with 66 General Adult Psychiatry beds, 46 Psychiatry of Old Age beds, and a 67-bed Secure Care Centre split across medium and low secure wards.
• Stracathro Hospital, Angus — home to the Susan Carnegie Centre, which runs a dementia assessment ward (Willow) and a functional mental health assessment ward (Rowan) for Angus, alongside other Stracathro-based services.
• A wider network of smaller community hospitals across Angus and Perth and Kinross, including sites at Arbroath, Blairgowrie, Crieff and Pitlochry.

Which of these sites a role sits at matters — day-to-day pressures differ genuinely between an acute post at Ninewells, a mental health post at Murray Royal or Stracathro, and a Perth Royal Infirmary post, as the sections below make clear.

Ninewells: teaching hospital and Major Trauma Centre

Ninewells' clearest point of distinction is its dual status as a University of Dundee Medical School teaching hospital and one of Scotland's four Major Trauma Centres (alongside Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow), a status it's held since 2016. It anchors the East of Scotland Trauma Network, which NHS Fife also depends on: Fife has no Major Trauma Centre of its own, and its Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy operates as a Trauma Unit that refers or transfers seriously injured patients to Ninewells rather than treating major trauma in-house. Anyone considering a trauma, orthopaedic, emergency medicine or critical care role at Ninewells should expect a genuinely regional trauma caseload, not a purely local one.

The teaching link is longstanding, not recent — Ninewells was the second purpose-built medical school in the UK. Beyond trauma and teaching, it carries real depth in cancer care and leukaemia research, medical genetics, and was an early UK adopter of laparoscopic and robotic surgery — worth knowing if a specific specialty, not trauma, is what draws you to Dundee. NHS Tayside also has a genuine public health landmark: in 2020 it became the first health region globally to report eliminating hepatitis C as a public health threat, hitting the Scottish Government's 2024 target four years early.

Healthcare Improvement Scotland: recent findings

Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) is Scotland's equivalent of England's Care Quality Commission — it inspects NHS hospitals and services and publishes individual findings and improvement action plans, rather than a single trust-wide star rating. The honest, current picture for NHS Tayside comes from two rounds of inspection: an unannounced inspection in January 2025, and a follow-up round published in June 2026.

The 27-29 January 2025 unannounced inspection covered Ninewells' acute hospital services and, for the first time ever at Ninewells, carried out a dedicated "safe delivery of care" inspection of its maternity services. Acute services came out relatively well: 10 areas of good practice, 1 recommendation and 14 requirements. Maternity services fared less well: 9 areas of good practice, but 3 recommendations and 20 requirements — concerning enough that HIS scheduled an unannounced follow-up visit specifically to check on remediation.

That follow-up took place the week of 16 February 2026 and was published on 16 June 2026. The picture at Ninewells was genuinely mixed rather than uniformly bad: inspectors found 3 new areas of good practice and noted "significant improvements in the safe storage of medications and completion of paperwork," but 3 of the original requirements were still not met and were carried forward, alongside 2 new or updated requirements — including continuing concerns about clinical waste and hazardous product storage. The same round of publications covered a parallel follow-up at Perth Royal Infirmary, and the news there was worse: 1 previous requirement carried forward, another only partially met, and 6 entirely new requirements, with the Chief Inspector specifically flagging persistent hand hygiene compliance problems that had already been raised previously. HIS judged the situation serious enough to schedule a full unannounced inspection at Perth Royal Infirmary rather than treat it as resolved by a routine follow-up.

Read the source reports directly on Healthcare Improvement Scotland's own inspection reports page before applying to a specific department, and check for anything published more recently than September 2026 — HIS runs a rolling national inspection programme, and Perth Royal Infirmary in particular is due further scrutiny.

Mental health services governance: still unresolved

This is a genuinely current, unresolved problem, not a historical footnote, so it gets its own section rather than a passing mention. A highly critical independent inquiry into NHS Tayside's mental health services was published in 2020. In response, NHS Tayside set up a Whole System Change Programme (WSCP) in 2023 to deliver the reforms that inquiry called for.

Audit Scotland's 2024/25 audit of NHS Tayside, published 20 November 2025, found that five years on from that original inquiry, the WSCP's own governance and leadership arrangements remain "complicated, unclear and not working well." Progress isn't being reported transparently enough to allow proper scrutiny, and there's still a lack of clarity about the purpose, roles and responsibilities of the various groups meant to be delivering improvements. The WSCP has also had to reduce the scope of its own activity because of limited skills and capacity. Perhaps most tellingly for anyone weighing a mental health role specifically: a 2018 decision to consolidate all inpatient mental health care onto a single site — which would presumably reshape the current Murray Royal / Stracathro split described above — is, in Audit Scotland's own words, not clear to be on track, seven years after the decision was taken. The Auditor General's assessment was blunt: "urgent action is needed to be clear on the priorities for improvement, with specific actions, timescales and costs detailed."

NHS Tayside's own response has been to say it has been developing a new direction of travel for mental health and learning disability services since July 2025, working to respond directly to the Audit Scotland findings. That's a genuine, current effort — but as of the most recent published audit, the underlying governance problems Audit Scotland identified had not been resolved. Anyone applying into NHS Tayside's mental health services, at Murray Royal, Stracathro or elsewhere, should read Audit Scotland's full 2024/25 report directly before doing so, and check for a more recent update if one has since been published.

The Sam Eljamel public inquiry

This is a serious, sensitive matter involving real patient harm, and FrontlinePay's aim here is to state the verified facts plainly and factually, with sources, rather than either sensationalising or minimising it.

Sam Eljamel was a consultant neurosurgeon at Ninewells Hospital from 1995 until he was placed under supervision and then suspended in December 2013, formally resigning on 31 May 2014. He is believed to have harmed as many as 200 former patients. In September 2023, the Scottish Government announced a statutory public inquiry under the Inquiries Act 2005 into his professional practice at NHS Tayside, chaired by Lord Weir. The inquiry examines his appointment and career trajectory, the circumstances of his 2013 supervision and suspension, whether information about concerns was concealed, and whether NHS Tayside's systems adequately protected patient safety — with a remit to recommend improvements to prevent recurrence.

A serious new development occurred during the inquiry itself. In October 2024, Lord Weir issued an explicit "do not destroy" order covering documents relevant to the inquiry, including theatre records. On 24 July 2025, NHS Tayside staff nonetheless destroyed approximately 40 hard-copy theatre logbooks covering the period of Eljamel's patients between 1995 and 2013 — directly contrary to that order. NHS Tayside reported the destruction to Police Scotland itself. An independent external review of the incident, carried out by AAB and published in August 2026, concluded there was "no malicious intent" and attributed the destruction to "inadequate" records systems and processes rather than deliberate concealment — but it also found that NHS Tayside took roughly three months after discovering the logbooks had been destroyed before starting additional checks on other records relevant to the inquiry. NHS Tayside's chief executive, Nicky Connor, personally apologised for the destruction at the inquiry but said she had no intention of resigning over it. Some of Eljamel's former patients have since publicly accused NHS Tayside of failing its duty of candour over how the destruction was handled and disclosed.

As of this page's last update, the inquiry is actively ongoing: its first section 1 evidential hearings began on 8 September 2026 and were scheduled to run for four weeks, covering Eljamel's career trajectory, the 2013 supervision arrangements, and NHS Tayside's document management and retention systems — the same systems implicated in the 2025 logbook destruction. Witnesses in this first phase include former MSP Liz Smith, who represented a number of Eljamel's former patients, and NHS Tayside's current chief executive, alongside representatives of the Scottish Government, the University of Dundee and relevant regulatory bodies. Anyone considering a role at Ninewells, particularly in neurosurgery, clinical governance or records management, should follow developments directly via the Eljamel Inquiry's own website, which livestreams hearings and publishes transcripts, rather than relying on this page for anything more recent than September 2026.

Staff experience and iMatter

NHS Scotland measures staff experience board-wide through its annual iMatter survey, reported nationally via gov.scot. Nationally, the 2025 Employee Engagement Index (EEI) across NHS Scotland was 77, one point down on 2024, returning to the 2023 level. FrontlinePay could not independently verify a single confirmed NHS Tayside-specific EEI score from the published sources checked for this page — the detailed board-by-board breakdown sits inside gov.scot's iMatter 2025 tables rather than a simple public summary — so treat any specific NHS Tayside EEI figure you see elsewhere with some caution unless it links back to that data directly.

What is specifically confirmed for NHS Tayside: its iMatter response rate fell to 53% in 2025, down from 56% in 2024 and continuing a longer decline from 65% in 2017. A falling response rate doesn't tell you what staff who did respond actually said, but a multi-year downward trend in participation is itself worth weighing, particularly set against the mental health governance concerns and the Eljamel inquiry developments covered above — both of which plausibly affect how comfortable staff feel engaging with organisational surveys. Check NHS Tayside's own published iMatter results directly if staff experience data for a specific department matters to your decision.

Pay at NHS Tayside

The Agenda for Change band framework — Band 2 through Band 9 — is the same UK-wide, so a role at NHS Tayside maps directly onto its equivalent band in England, Wales or Northern Ireland. What's genuinely different is that NHS Scotland negotiates and confirms its own annual pay deal through the Scottish Terms and Conditions Committee, separately from the independent NHS Pay Review Body process that recommends pay for England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

For 2026/27, NHS Scotland's Agenda for Change staff have a confirmed 3.75% uplift, part of a two-year pay deal agreed in 2025 worth more than £700 million, following a 4.25% uplift in 2025/26. The deal also carries a built-in inflation guarantee: each year's increase must be at least one percentage point above average CPI inflation for that calendar year — which is why the 2025/26 headline uplift was adjusted upward to 4.4% once 2025 CPI was confirmed at 3.4%. Full band-by-band figures, including how Scotland's restructured pay spine compares point-for-point with England's, are in our dedicated NHS Scotland pay scales 2026/27 guide. As with any negotiated position revisited annually, don't assume this year's specific gap versus England holds automatically going forward — check the current pay circular before relying on a figure.

No Dundee or Tayside weighting

Unlike London, where HCAS adds a location-based supplement reflecting higher living costs, NHS Scotland doesn't run an equivalent zoned scheme anywhere in the country. Pay at NHS Tayside is simply the applicable Scotland Agenda for Change rate for your band and point — Dundee, Perth and Angus all carry a notably lower cost of living than Edinburgh or London, but that isn't reflected as a downward adjustment either. It's a flat national rate regardless of where in Scotland you're based, consistent with every other NHS Scotland health board this site covers.

How it compares with NHS Fife

NHS Fife is the most directly relevant comparison for anyone weighing NHS Tayside, not because the two boards are similar in size, but because they're operationally linked: Fife has no Major Trauma Centre of its own and depends on Ninewells through the East of Scotland Trauma Network for its most seriously injured patients.

In other words, choosing between NHS Tayside and NHS Fife for a trauma, orthopaedic or major acute role isn't a pay decision — it's a decision about whether you want to work inside the region's actual Major Trauma Centre or at a Trauma Unit that refers its most serious cases elsewhere. For mental health roles, weigh NHS Tayside's unresolved governance concerns, covered above, against NHS Fife's own record before deciding on service and location alone.

Careers, training and the University of Dundee

Ninewells' status as a University of Dundee Medical School teaching hospital means genuine, longstanding academic infrastructure sits alongside day-to-day clinical work — clinical academic posts, undergraduate and postgraduate medical training placements, and research programmes in cancer, leukaemia and medical genetics that a purely district general hospital wouldn't offer. Trauma and orthopaedic trainees rotating through NHS Tayside as part of Scotland's East of Scotland training programme get direct exposure to Ninewells' Major Trauma Centre caseload as part of that rotation. For anyone specifically weighing an academic or research-linked career path in Scotland, Ninewells sits alongside Edinburgh's BioQuarter and Glasgow's university hospital sites as one of the country's genuine teaching and research hubs — smaller in scale than either, but with real depth in its specific strengths.

That said, training and academic strength at Ninewells doesn't offset the currently unresolved concerns documented above — anyone considering neurosurgery, clinical governance or mental health roles specifically should weigh those sections directly rather than assuming they cancel out.

Compare NHS Tayside and find your match

Rather than relying on general impressions of "Scotland" or assuming every Scottish health board carries the same risks and strengths, it's worth putting your own numbers and priorities against NHS Tayside directly.

Related pages

The bottom line

NHS Tayside is a genuinely capable, teaching-linked health board built around one dominant site — Ninewells is a real Major Trauma Centre with longstanding University of Dundee research and training links, and NHS Fife's own patients depend on it for major trauma care. But this is also a board carrying two serious, current and unresolved problems that a fair guide can't leave out: Healthcare Improvement Scotland found unmet requirements at both Ninewells and Perth Royal Infirmary as recently as June 2026; Audit Scotland found NHS Tayside's mental health services governance still "complicated, unclear and not working well" five years after the original 2020 inquiry that was meant to fix it; and the statutory public inquiry into former Ninewells neurosurgeon Sam Eljamel — complicated further by NHS Tayside's own 2025 destruction of relevant records — is in the middle of live evidential hearings as this page was last updated. None of that erases the genuine strengths above, but weigh both sides honestly for the specific site and service you're applying to, check Healthcare Improvement Scotland, Audit Scotland and the Eljamel Inquiry's own websites for anything published more recently than September 2026, and compare directly with the tools above before deciding.

Frequently asked questions